“The editor is there to do two things: to make the book as polished and professional as she can and to help you and the publisher avoid infringement suits. There are no brownie points for refusing reasonable edits. My first editor [Suzanne James] taught me: “An editor is not dismembering your baby; she’s polishing your gem.” To that, I added: “Sometimes you have to cut off the rough edges before the soft cloth comes out.” While you may not agree on precisely what changes need made to smooth the work, you should work with the editor to come to a compromise and not dismiss the concerns outright. Chances are, if the editor sees a problem, the readers will as well. Remember, what you see in your mind’s eye is often filling in the blanks between the typed lines, because you know the subject so well. For a reader to see the same thing, it has to all be on the page.”
Brenna Lyons, author of the EPIC’s e-Book Award-winning TIME CURRENTS
As someone who’s worked as an editor, I have to say that’s a fabulous attitude, Brenna! The key is for that editor to polish without completely changing the shape of the stone–you want someone who’s going to refine, not change your voice :)